Colombian vs Guatemalan Coffee: How They Taste and Which to Pick

Short answer: Colombian coffee tends to be bright and balanced, with fruit up front and chocolate underneath. Guatemalan coffee tends to be richer and fuller, with dark chocolate, sweetness and a little spice. If you like a lively, juicy cup, start with Colombia. If you like something deeper that holds up to milk, start with Guatemala.

Both are washed Latin American coffees grown at altitude, so they share a clean, smooth base. The differences come from where they grow, the varieties planted, and the soil.

Side by side

Colombia Guatemala
Our region Medellin, Antioquia Antigua
Altitude 1,300 to 1,500 m 1,200 to 1,616 m
Varieties Castillo, Caturra, Colombia, Typica Bourbon, Catuai, Caturra, Typica
Process Washed, dried in solar dryers Washed, sun dried
Roast Medium Medium
Tasting notes Dried orange, berry, chocolate Dark chocolate, bright fruit, butterscotch
Body Medium Medium to full

What Colombian coffee tastes like

Colombia grows coffee along three branches of the Andes, and many regions harvest twice a year. That steady supply of fresh crop is one reason Colombian coffee is so consistent.

Our Colombia comes from smallholder farmers around Medellin. In the cup you get dried orange and berry first, then milk chocolate as it cools. It is the coffee we recommend to people who say they just want a really good cup of coffee.

What Guatemalan coffee tastes like

Antigua sits in a valley ringed by volcanoes, and the volcanic soil gives its coffee a reputation for depth and sweetness. Guatemalan beans are often graded SHB, or Strictly Hard Bean, which means they grew high enough to mature slowly into dense beans.

Our Guatemala leads with dark chocolate, with bright fruit in the middle and a butterscotch finish. It has a bit more weight than the Colombia, so it stands up well to milk.

Which one should you buy?

  • Black coffee drinkers who like brightness: Colombia.
  • Milk, cream or latte drinkers: Guatemala.
  • Pour over or Chemex: Colombia shows off its fruit with these methods.
  • French press or moka pot: Guatemala's body and chocolate shine here.
  • Can't decide: get a 12 oz bag of each and brew them side by side. It is the fastest way to learn what you like.

How to brew them

Start with 1 gram of coffee per 16 grams of water (about 2 tablespoons per 6 oz cup) and water just off the boil. For Colombia, try a pour over. For Guatemala, try a French press with a four-minute steep. Both make good cold brew too.

If you like these, try next

  • Like the Colombia? Try Costa Rica, which is lighter and sweeter, with honey and apple.
  • Like the Guatemala? Try Nicaragua or Honduras for more chocolate and caramel.

Every MAKR coffee is roasted the day it ships, with free shipping anywhere in the US. Shop single origin coffee.


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published